Help... we are lost in mattress hunting

Hello mattress sages,

My wife and I have been hunting a queen mattress under 1500CAD, but has failed everything we tried… It’s been few months since our last good sleep I guess… Very exhausted… Could someone suggest good option for us?

We are an average and light weight couple who are combination sleepers(back-70%, Side-30%), reside in Canada. We started to search a mattress because our 8 years old traditional one showed distinctive sag. The first mattress we tried was Emma Performance Hybrid, which immediately failed as its rock slab like firmness. This experience steered our mind to softer option that was Silk and Snow hybrid Plush. But our hip and shoulders sank too much due to its excessive softness then that caused spinal misalignment with pain. Lastly, we have been testing Silk and Snow Organic Hybrid. This is… good but only when we lie on our back, not on our side since it makes my arms numb.

Yes, there are fine options we seem to love like Beautyrest Micaela mattress but it cost $2100. Please give us ideas what we should look at next.